The part of you that loves providing for others helped create your success and give your family a better life.
But how much of that life did you get to enjoy?
Maybe you missed your mother’s 80th birthday celebration for another business trip. Yes, maybe that business deal would’ve fallen through without you. But now she’s gone, and no amount of money can buy you another day with her.
Over thirty years, those choices added up. Your partner has years of memories you barely share. You’ve given so much, yet you feel tired and wonder where your life went.
Someone who’s spent a lifetime judging hours by how much they get done may still have no idea how much joy a single hour can bring.
That’s the Provider’s Trap. You keep giving up time with the people you love because you’ve barely learned how to derive full enjoyment from that time.
In this episode, you’ll discover how to spot that Trap and start choosing what you actually want to focus your remaining years on. You could feel more deeply loved, grow closer to your partner, and find more joy than you’ve ever known.
Listen now, while the people you want to share that life with are still around.
Show highlights include:
- How your provider parts can betray your own self interest for other people you barely even know (1:42)
- The insidious reason behind why exhaustion has become your default state (4:59)
- Why imagining yourself on your deathbed is the single best way to avoid putting lesser goods above your loved ones (and why so many achievers don’t realize this until it’s too late) (8:59)
- How to become a student of regret and grief today so you don’t end up with decades of unlived life at the end (14:47)
- The tragedy of failing to upgrade your decision-making process as you accumulate wealth and how it makes you miss out on life’s special moments (20:55)
For more about David Tian, go here: https://www.davidtianphd.com/about/
Feeling like success in one area of life has come at the expense of another?
Maybe you’ve crushed it in your career, but your relationships feel strained. Or you’ve built the life you thought you wanted, yet there’s still something important missing.
I’ve put together a free 3-minute assessment to help you see what’s really holding you back. Answer a few simple questions, and you’ll get instant access to a personalized masterclass that speaks directly to where you are right now.
It’s fast. It’s practical. And it could change the way you approach leadership, love, and fulfillment.
Take the first step here → https://dtphd.com/quiz
*****
Listen to the episode on your favorite podcast platform:
Apple Podcasts:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/beyond-success/id1570318182
Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/4LAVM2zYO4xfGxVRATSQxN
Audible/Amazon:
https://www.audible.com/podcast/Beyond-Success/B08K57V4JS?qid=1624532264
Podbean:
https://www.podbean.com/podcast-detail/bkcgh-1f9774/Beyond-Success-Podcast
SoundCloud:
https://soundcloud.com/user-980450970
TuneIn:
http://tun.in/pkn9
Note: Scroll Below for Transcription
Welcome to the Beyond Success Podcast: Psychology and Philosophy for Achievers on the Bigger Questions Behind What You’re Building, and I’m your host, David Tian.
Let’s do a thought experiment. Picture this: you’re on your deathbed, your life partner is there. At some point, the two of you get talking about your mother who has passed, and your partner does an impression of what your mother said the day you flew her younger sister, who’s deathly afraid of flying so hasn’t visited in years. Her younger sister surprised her at her 80th birthday. You know what she said.
You’ve heard your spouse tell that story for years, and now you realize you’d give almost anything so that you could remember hearing your mother say it, because you weren’t there. You were on a business trip. You paid for the flight that brought your mother and her sister together. Your partner spent months arranging it, but when your mother walked in, you were in Hong Kong for a client meeting. [00:57.2]
Your chief of staff or your vice chairman, some other deputy knew the client back then just as well. They could have taken the meeting, but you went because the client prefers to see you, and all things considered, you thought it would be better if you went, and you probably were right about that. The meeting probably did go a little bit better because you were there. But from your deathbed, how much better would that meeting have had to go for you for you to choose it again over your mother?
Now replace the mother in this scene with your own person. Maybe it would be your intimate partner or another parent, or a sibling, or the friend who knew you long before anybody cared about what you did for a living or how you made your money.
Now, what makes the choice so difficult is that you would be asking a sensible question: Would it help if I went to the meeting? The answer is, of course, it would. You’re really good at your job. You’re the boss. But what you can see most clearly from your deathbed and could have asked at the time back then is what your being at that meeting was worth to the client versus what your being somewhere else would have meant to you. [02:09.1]
Over the years, probably since you were very young, parts of you that provide and found value in providing found their self-worth, your self-worth in being the provider, became dominant in your personality or your psyche and drove you to a lot of success. As a result, you came to trust this way of loving people. Providing for others became one of your default ways of showing love to them.
Think back to when your business or company was still small and cash flow was very tight. and your family had good reason to be anxious or afraid. If showing up in person to a meeting could keep an account or close a deal, you would take that flight, and the people that you took care of would sleep better because you were willing to go to that meeting. [02:59.2]
That mattered to you back then and it contributed in a big way to the life that you have built, the success that you have now, and working hard to be able to provide for those that you love was incredibly and is incredibly satisfying. You developed abilities and skills that you wouldn’t otherwise have known you could have. You pushed yourself beyond the limits that you thought you had. People came to trust your judgment and you could pay a bill that your parents once would have worried about for weeks or years—and being able to do that for somebody that you love feels very good for a very good reason, right?
But now you’re not at the beginning of building that company, are you? Back then, you could tell yourself honestly that you were working so hard for the people that you love, to take care of them, but now that you’re not in emergency mode or survival mode anymore, you should ask yourself this question: What did you hope all that providing would let you and those people that you cared about experience together? And looking back, how much of that have you actually had? [04:04.4]
So, at one point early on, being there personally at that meeting might have made the difference between keeping and losing the client, or losing and closing the deal. But let’s say 20 years or 30 years or more later, you have an excellent team and your family is financially secure, and now it would still be a little bit better if you went to the meeting and those parts of you that see their primary job as providing got everyone safely through those early years would hear that as roughly the same reason.
Early on, being there would have made the difference in closing or losing the deal, and decades later, now it would help you only a little bit. The difference between those two scenarios is where a surprising amount of the rest of your life can get sucked up. [04:59.3]
Now, a common symptom of this trap is that, let’s say, three decades later, the main thing you feel happens to be exhaustion. That’s almost a default sort of state. You’re tired and you feel it in your body. Fast forward through hundreds of decisions, like the one about the Hong Kong scenario, include the trips that you loved and the years when people genuinely needed you, and then give an honest accounting of all the rest of those decisions, like the project that you agreed to because the chairman back then asked you personally to take care of it. You knew enough about it to know that the next 18 months would be incredibly tedious.
Or the meeting overseas that had you go across two continents that you could have handed over to someone else, except that going yourself was a lot easier for you than having the conversation about why you were sending someone else. [05:55.6]
Or the weekends that the new project swallowed after you agreed to it, and by then, you’d already given your word and staying late really was the responsible thing to do for those months, and the decision that you had some freedom over happened to be six months earlier than the point when you realized how much of your life it would swallow up.
Then one day somebody asks what those years were like. Now, you could probably give a very articulate and clear and substantial account of what you achieved business-wise or in the company—probably you have put that on your LinkedIn or your CV or résumé maybe—or maybe you’ve already recounted this to your board over several meetings and really try to remember what you enjoyed about those hours over those years that you devoted to those particular projects. [06:46.1]
Notice that if a great many of those hours, a big percentage of those hours, were much like one another. You may have difficulty remembering much about them at all in specifics—but then you hear your spouse and your old friend talking about that one weekend 20 years ago, and they can go on and on for half an hour laughing, and that gives you an answer to “Where did the years go?” You actually know where they went. What troubles you the most is how little of what you spent those years on you would actually care to experience again.
So, there is an answer to “How come I’ve provided so much over the years, but feel so little besides exhaustion?” The answer is you did get something out of finishing all of those projects. You felt useful, perhaps proud, and perhaps relieved that the hard work was over, so you thought, and then you took on another project—and after three decades or more, you’ve had a lot of practice getting through demanding weeks and months, and a lot less practice enjoying the people that you were getting through all of that hard work for. [08:03.3]
Now, that’s just a mundane example, missed special occasions, but think about your intimate or special partner, your spouse, your wife, your husband. They, during all of your hardworking years, formed memories, friendships, and interests during those years. A lot of those stories that you used to ask about eventually took so much explaining to give you the background and the context that they got so hard to share that they didn’t bother to share them. You can still be very devoted to each other over those years, and still discover when you finally have more time together, how much of each other’s lives you now need to be caught up on and have missed already.
Now, the case for being there, present psychologically and emotionally, goes well beyond merely giving your family more of your attention, like it’s some kind of duty or obligation. Instead, consider what they might have given you over all of those years and decades, if you had been available physically and psychologically, emotionally to receive it. [09:10.2]
While you were worrying about your business, what was your partner afraid of? What were they looking forward to the most? What did they once think that the two of you would do when the business could manage without you finally for a while? There’s a special kind of grief in finally asking and finding out that there was something that they wanted very much but years ago that they eventually just stopped wanting, because it hurt too much to keep hoping for it.
This applies not only to your intimate partner, but to your kids as they grow up and you can’t get those years of their lives back anymore. But, hey, it’s actually never too late. You can still make some room for whatever remains possible now. The people you love may have an answer today that would surprise you. You could come to know them well at this age and you could give them the pleasure of knowing that you still want to find out who they are and were, even after all these years. [10:12.0]
Now, one of the most powerful thought experiments psychologically and emotionally is the deathbed thought experiment that we started with. Death anxiety, the fear of dying, is directly proportional to the recognition of how much of your life you’ve left unlived. Reflect more deeply and focus more closely on what you really mean when you say to yourself that you wished you had more time. One of the most common things that that means is that “there is a way I always imagined the two of us or our family would live, and we haven’t actually lived that way yet.” [10:52.4]
Sometimes, the real problem isn’t more effort or more motivation. It’s knowing the right direction. A lot of people listening to this podcast are capable and driven. Things still look fine on paper, but life still feels strangely flat. When that happens, more advice usually isn’t the answer. Clarity is.
I’ve put together a short assessment that takes about two minutes. It’s simply a way to see which area deserves your attention most right now, whether that’s relationships, decision-making, or how pressure is being handled day to day. Based on your responses, you’ll be sent a short set of master classes related to that area.
If that sounds useful, you can find it at DTPhD.com/quiz. That’s “dtphd.com/quiz.”
The deathbed thought experiment brings those thoughts into focus. So, facing this scenario earlier in your life can change what you do with the rest of your life while you’re still alive, and it might even take another person’s death to bring these thoughts home. [11:56.6]
Imagine retiring after decades of saying the two of you would travel once you could get away for more than a week or once you retire, but then your partner passes away before you retire—and, of course, you grieve for the person you knew, but you will also grieve for the life together that you are both counting on in the future. You had planned carefully for how long the money had to last. The plan, though, also depended on both of you having the years left to enjoy that.
A senior professor that I came to know very well in my graduate student years always had a rigorous international travel schedule, and he always jokingly complained that he could never bring his wife or his kids along on those conference travels to beautiful places, because he actually doesn’t see any of the things beyond the conference room or the conference hotel. He didn’t allow himself to enjoy the travel, and he didn’t bring them along because he just wanted to get it over with, but he kept saying yes to a lot of work travel. [12:59.5]
One year before his retirement, he said in an interview that what he and his wife looked forward to the most in retirement was to finally be able to travel together to these beautiful places that he only traveled to alone and only saw the inside of the conference hotel. Unfortunately, a few months later, he passed away from cancer.
Now, the question to focus on is always going to be what your life is asking of you now, and for many listeners, after so many years spent answering what the world or your loved ones, or the people who are your dependents that you’re providing for, after so many years spent answering what they were asking of you, perhaps now part of an honest answer to that question would be to admit that some of what you gave up mattered more to you than you let yourself know at the time and mattered more to your loved ones than you let yourself admit at the time. [13:58.4]
Some losses came with decisions that you would still defend now. Maybe the family really did need you abroad for that year so that you were absent then to provide at that critical period. You can believe that you chose well back then and still now feel sad about what you and everybody else missed. Others came with decisions that you would reverse in a heartbeat. Let yourself remember those two and let those sink in. Reflect on those.
If every pang of regret sends you straight back to the argument about how hard you had to work, then decisions like the one we started with, with that meeting in Hong Kong, those decisions get lumped in with that emergency year that you had to buckle down and save the company. As a result of avoiding that kind of depth of reflection, the next optional trip ends up getting lumped in with the year you saved the company and you make the same choice that you will only regret later. Let grief and regret now be your teacher. [15:07.0]
Now let’s widen the lens and widen the focus, and ask this question: How much joy can a single hour hold? In the Analects, Confucius listens to several students describe what they’d like to do if their abilities were recognized, and as a result, financially rewarded.
One of his top students imagines going out in late spring with his best friends and bathing in the river, the famous Yi River, and enjoying the breeze and singing on the way home, and Confucius says, “I’m with the student. I’m down with that plan.”
Now let’s put Confucius’s question to you. You want your family to flourish for generations. What do you picture them doing on a leisurely afternoon when they are flourishing? If some of them are down at the river, singing in the breeze on the way home, you might reasonably think, Yes, that’s a big part of why I work so hard. [16:08.8]
If you discovered they’d be delighted to have you with them, not just working hard on their behalf somewhere else, how much would you be tempted to race back to the office that afternoon to rationalize that you are financing this flourishing instead of enjoying it or experiencing it, not only on your behalf but for your loved ones, too?
If you’ve become accustomed to judging the worth of an hour by what it can produce, then you still have got a lot to learn about how much joy an hour can actually hold. If the most joy or fulfillment, or love or connection that you’ve ever gotten out of a single hour is, let’s say, one unit, then one is the number you would use when you decide whether to take that next meeting. You know pretty well what an hour of your professional time could produce. [17:06.7]
However, your estimate of what that hour with someone that you love could actually hold comes from a much smaller sample. When you are fully mentally, emotionally, psychologically present with someone or with the situation or with the environment, or with something, or with some event, when you are in flow at that moment, time slows down.
That time dilation effect that you experience, being fully present in the moment, means that you can absorb or suck up, or experience or squeeze out of that hour 10 units of pleasure or enjoyment, or love or flow, or connection. [17:51.5]
Then imagine you get more and more practice at being present, at being in flow in the present moment, engaging all of your senses in the moment, fully mindful of what you’re experiencing and who you’re with in the conversation or the interaction, or the event or that moment. Not only are you able to derive more enjoyment out of that hour, you’re able to continue this state for multiple hours. Then it becomes a kind of default state that you can sustain over days, weeks, years. It becomes your default way of interacting with the world and experiencing time and your life.
This is only possible with a lot of practice, but if you’re mostly going passively through your personal life, you’ve actually been missing out on a great portion of what could be derived from the time that you have in your personal life, and you equate the enjoyment and flow and meaning of the personal time with what you experience in your professional life—which means that you vastly underestimate the value to you of that personal time, the quality time with those that you love and are taken care of. [19:01.8]
Now go back to that example of your mother’s 80th birthday when you flew her sister in to surprise her. You bring something that nobody else could, who was there. You grew up with your mother. You might recognize the laugh that she hadn’t laughed since you were a boy, and there’s a version of that hour that your wife, your spouse, your partner, could have had only with you beside her, experiencing it with her.
The great Chinese poet Wang Wei notices the evening light on the green moss and can meditate on that for a long time, writing beautiful poems. Lin Yutang takes seriously the pleasure that friends can have over hours of tea. The point here is that someone can spend decades acquiring the wealth to have these leisurely afternoons and still have spent relatively little time developing the ability or the skill to enjoy such afternoons. [19:59.2]
So, here’s the bigger question for you: What if you have been deciding how much time, how many hours you can afford to give the people that you love, based on how little, relatively, of that joy you have experienced so far from an hour?
Now let’s deal with perhaps the most common objection to this point, and that is that “I still love building things. Some of the best friends I’ve met are people that I met through the business and I’ve still got a lot of plans and projects that I want to do,” and that’s all great. I’m sure that those ventures all are meaningful to you, and some of the hours that you’ll cherish most looking back may very well be the evenings that you spent at the office with those people or on those business dinners, discussing things with those people, hashing things out with them. [20:55.2]
The point I’m making isn’t to retire now. You absolutely could and should continue to do meaningful work, but realize that the rubric you were using to decide whether to accept an invitation or a project back then, when you were starting out, should be different from the way that you are assessing the invitations now.
Now, instead of just asking the question “Who would benefit if I went to the meeting?” now ask, “What actually depends on me here? What would my being there at that meeting mean to the people I love the most? And which of those things do I want most for myself?” and that last question counts even if your family is taken care of and nobody is complaining, and they can all afford to go on that trip or whatever that thing is without you. You are allowed to want to be there to experience it. [21:51.0]
Now, considering that the deathbed thought experiment is so powerful, let’s return to that. Go back to your spouse, your wife, your husband telling the story of your mother’s 80th birthday. You’ll always wish you had been there. No decision you can make now would give you that time back. But now think of the people who are still alive in your life today whose stories you still have a chance to be part of and who still have a chance to be part of your story.
Some of them, you might be astonished to discover, would be surprised to learn how often you have wished you could spend more quality time with them, because from their side, you seemed pretty happy to take those meetings abroad. Again, imagine reaching the end of your life, turning and looking over at your partner and telling your partner, “I’d have loved another 10 years with you.”
Now, that can mean two very different things—you might be wishing for the years together you always thought you would have had, or the two of you might look into each other’s eyes and know exactly what you would have loved about another 10 years because you enjoyed the last 10 so much. [23:08.0]
Now, I’ll leave you with two final reflection questions: Who are you thinking of when you say you would give anything for more time with them? And while you still have more time, what do you want that life together to be like? [23:27.2]